The Individuality of the Narrator Al-Saduq Between Acceptance andRejection: Muhammad bin Ishaq is an example

Abstract

There is no doubt that one of the important issues related to the hadith and its causes, which has been discussed a lot, especially in recent times, is the issue of the individuality of Al-Saduq narrator. Is he accepted absolutely or rejected absolutely, or are there details and conditions in which he is accepted and rejected? This article deals with this important issue with research and scrutiny. One of the narrators whose individuality has been widely discussed is the Imam of Sirs and Battles, “Muhammad bin Ishaq bin Yasar.” The matter has been established among the hadith scholars that he is in the rank of “Al-Saduq,” that is, he is just, but he has lightness of control. In this article, we will discuss the critics’ position on its individuality from a theoretical and practical perspective, as will follow